Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Definition of Autism in Updated Psychiatric Clinical Manual

New Definition of Autism in Updated Psychiatric Clinical Manual Will Not Exclude Most Children With Autism, Expert Says

ScienceDaily (Oct. 2, 2012) — Parents should not worry that proposed changes to the medical criteria redefining a diagnosis of autism will leave their children excluded and deemed ineligible for psychiatric and medical care, says a team of researchers led by psychologists at Weill Cornell Medical College.

Their new study, published in the October 1 issue of the American Journal of Psychiatry, is the largest to date that has tried to unpack the differences between the diagnostic criteria for autism spectrum disorders in the fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) and the proposed revision in the fifth edition (DSM-5), which is expected to be published in May 2013. These manuals provide diagnostic criteria for people seeking mental-health-related medical services.
"I know that parents worry, but I don't believe there is any substantial reason to fear that children who need to be diagnosed with autism spectrum disorders, and provided with vital services, will not be included in the new criteria in this updated manual," says the study's senior investigator, Dr. Catherine Lord, director of the Center for Autism and the Developing Brain at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital's Westchester campus, along with its affiliated medical schools Weill Cornell Medical College andColumbia University College of Physicians and Surgeons.
At issue is whether DSM-5 will "capture" the same individuals diagnosed with different forms of autism by the DSM-IV. The DSM-5 proposal redefines autism as a single category -- autism spectrum disorder (ASD) -- whereas DSM-IV had multiple categories and included Autistic Disorder, Asperger's Disorder, and Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified (PDD-NOS).
Critics have particularly worried that among the excluded will be children now diagnosed with PPD-NOS and Asperger's disorder. That isn't the case, says Dr. Lord, who is also a DeWitt Wallace Senior Scholar at Weill Cornell and an attending psychologist at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital. The study, the largest to date and arguably, the most rigorous, finds that when relying on parent report, 91 percent of the 4,453 children in the sample currently diagnosed with a DSM-IV autism spectrum disorder would be diagnosed with ASD using DSM-V.
Many of the remaining nine percent would likely be reincluded once a clinician can offer input, says Dr. Lord, who is also a member of the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-5 Neurodevelopmental Disorders Work Group.
The study researchers also concluded that DSM-5 has higher specificity than DSM-IV--in their study, DSM-5 criteria resulted in fewer misclassifications.

Improving the Diagnostic Criteria
The study used three large databases to evaluate DSM-5 criteria in groups of children with DSM-IV clinical diagnoses. The analysis, which included a team of independent reviewers led by the study's lead author, Dr. Marisela Huerta of NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center, relied on a standardized 96-item parent report and a clinician-based measure of autism spectrum disorder impairments.
"These two instruments were particularly well-suited for the current study because they include items based on history and current behavior, and they take into account developmental level in their design," says Dr. Huerta, an instructor of psychology at Weill Cornell and a professional associate at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital. "This is consistent with DSM-5 criteria, which operationalize symptoms differently for individuals of different ages in order to account for the effect of development on ASD symptoms."

The changes proposed by DSM-5 are designed to better identify autism spectrum disorders and distinguish them from other conditions. According to Dr. Huerta, "The criteria for DSM-5 are actually more inclusive." For example, while DSM-IV criteria require evidence of difficulties related to autism prior to age 3, "DSM-5 says that a child has to show examples of unusual behavior in early childhood, with the idea that there is nothing sacrosanct about your third birthday."

Other changes proposed by DSM-5 include defining autism spectrum disorders by two sets of core features -- impaired social communication and social interactions, and restricted and repetitive behavior and interests. DSM-5 reorganizes the symptoms in these domains and includes those not previously included in DSM-IV, such as sensory interests and aversions.

The overall issue with DSM-IV was "not that a lot of people are diagnosed with autism who shouldn't be, but that there is a lot of confusion because the criteria were not very accurate," says Dr. Lord.

"DSM-5 deliberately added and organized things to try to bring in and better address the needs of people with autism spectrum disorders of all developmental levels and ages -- including girls, who were not represented as well as they should be in DSM-IV," Dr. Lord says. "The goal of DSM-5 is to better describe who has ASD in a way that matches up with what we know from research, which predicts who has the disorder and also reflects what clinicians are actually looking at."

Because of the newness of the proposed criteria, only a few studies have attempted to compare the criteria between the two DSM versions. "Our study is much broader, and it is important to note that we get very similar results when looking at three large data sets that were collected for different purposes, with diverse populations, and for various reasons," says Dr. Lord.

The study's other contributing authors are Dr. Somer L. Bishop of NewYork-Presbyterian/Weill Cornell Medical Center, Dr. Amie Duncan from Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, and graduate student Vanessa Hus from the University of Michigan.

The research was supported by grants from the National Institute of Mental Health and the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development.

Dr. Catherine Lord was involved in the development of some of the instruments used in this research and receives royalty income from the sale of those instruments.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. Call me old-fashioned, but I don't believe it is right that the senior investigating doctor for the new DSM-V, Dr. Catherine Lord, should gain monetarily for her role in creating the new manual. This is a publicly funded venture--funded by the NIMH and the NICHHD--both taxpayer-funded entities. This smacks too much of Dick Cheney creating a war in Iraq so his investment in Halliburton could grow exponentially. We've seen enough of this kind of double-dipping by "public servants." Enough is enough. Hands out of the till, Dr. Lord.


  3. This blog has some of the smartest readers ever! Thank you Prudence

  4. Awesome article.

    Also visit my weblog: youtube converter

  5. Hold down an app for a second, and start turning
    off all the apps that you aren't using by pressing the "minus" button. The Lenmar 1530 m - Ah for the Amazon Kindle 1 e-reader is the first choice for consumers. Rechargeable batteries last longer than single use batteries before disposal and reduce the number of batteries you buy.

    Here is my webpage online radio -

  6. Without the internet, this is not possible to play these novoline games online
    and even they can't live online that they perform now with public for additional characteristics and completely attractive in a delusion earth to participate in a game. One way to test yourself is to deal yourself hand after hand in front of a mirror and watch yourself as you react to the cards. In our next article, we'll be tackling using SNES4i - Phone
    to do exactly that - play those old favorites, like Chono
    Trigger, Super Ghouls and Ghosts, or even
    Super Mario Bros 3.

    my webpage - myvideo downloader

  7. Without the internet, this is not possible to play these novoline games online
    and even they can't live online that they perform now with public for additional characteristics and completely attractive in a delusion earth to participate in a game. One way to test yourself is to deal yourself hand after hand in front of a mirror and watch yourself as you react to the cards. Each child is given 30 seconds to race to the pile and make as many matches as possible before time runs out.

    Also visit my web page :: radio sender

  8. "I see myself as, for lack of a better comparison, the Katy Perry of country music. Like any great city Chicago has top-notch attractions such as museums, buildings and zoo's. This is a welcome idea, especially if one misses the actual showing of a blockbuster flick in traditional movie houses.

    Here is my website:

  9. "I see myself as, for lack of a better comparison, the Katy Perry of country music. It is a good thing that a variety of programs which can help ambitious filmmakers find their niche is obtainable at entertainment Career Connection Jimi Petulla. While the pleasure inventory on India categorized incorporates adverts placed by models, hopeful actresses besides other different leisure professionals.

  10. Ad - Sense, like every other Google program, is managed entirely online, with no need
    for a Google home business kit. However, the MP3 player doesn't have an impressive volume buttons and the quality of sound is also not good. However, to ensure that you’re reaching people who are likely to become customers, you should research the audience of the Internet radio station and radio show.

    Also visit my blog post; Email Console

  11. Although diamond rings had been in existence for literally billions of
    years, they were not popular among general consumers. Such a restriction places this benefit out of reach for many owners.
    Be prepared however, to shell out more money for custom-made shirts as these
    are more expensive than retail items.

    Feel free to surf to my homepage ... buy

  12. So let's explore some of the most common reasons with the help of a theory which is based on my observations alone. Most people can't be bothered typing in a long and complex web
    address. Lots of handsets now make this possible so we have
    put together a list of the best phones for Facebook.

    Feel free to visit my web-site -

  13. Over time, many of these radio personnel will be readily
    agreeable to featuring the entrepreneur whenever they release
    new products or services. Remember that most dorm room radio stations out
    there may or may not be online from time to time and that cannot be blamed on the
    app, however this does hinder the experience of Internet radio on the i - Phone.
    Individuals have acquired different software and programe
    through which you could download these videos.

    Also visit my webpage ... 1

  14. Thankfully, our truck is equipped with extra radiators for towing our camping trailer so it didn't overheat, but it had a huge loss of power. Thus, these are NOT all-time "global warming" records, just ones in an historical weather context. This is easily fixed because below the plastic you find the regular screw holes which I used to install the PCI cards.

    Feel free to visit my web page;

  15. Every member of this family should be examined by those
    who feel called by Moose as they are inter-related.
    Sometimes, items come premixed but still have less packaging.
    The Ped Egg is one of the few infomercial products I've seen that actually works, and it is perfect for sloughing off your worst dried skin.

    My page Beauty

  16. Two family members will join together to increase their power,
    focus on another family member, convince each other they
    are right, and manipulate the family system. When we see where those lessons
    were learned and the significance they held in that learning,
    we can understand more about the importance they carry today.

    It allows you to do all the cool stuff, like engage in multiplayer games online, visit with friends via Kinect, stream movies and TV, listen to music and much, much more.

    Also visit my blog: edf energy

  17. I understand that those are the products designed
    by manufacturers to make them money and
    if they are endorsed by winning popular professionals, sales will be high.

    It should come as no surprise that i - Tunes is loaded full of pirate apps for i - Phone, i
    - Pod Touch, and i - Pad. If you want to be able to hit the ball
    further and harder, you should keep in mind to keep
    your grip on the bat loose, your swing should begin with your legs and hips, and
    finally, you must always follow your bat through.

    Feel free to surf to my web-site :: click the next document

  18. For instance, when you visit a news site, your Facebook profile pic
    often shows up in the comment section on articles so you can comment with your Facebook
    account. You don;t have to be fake, just forgive
    yourself for the bad pictures taken at a bad moment and praise yourself for the
    ones that give you respect. Follow the installation process after
    the download is complete.

    Also visit my web-site :: Suggested Site

  19. Perfect pan size we encourage you take them
    back to your hotel and have them prepared. One
    of the benefits of fishing is that it is not physically demanding.
    Yet sometimes a net is better to use because it usually
    doesn't harm the fish and will most likely be easier for you to prepare the fish for later.

    Also visit my homepage mouse click the next article

  20. Thanks foг the auѕрicіous writeup.
    Ιt іn faсt useԁ to be a enjoуment account it.
    Lоok adνanced to more іntгoԁucеd agгeeablе from you!
    By thе way, hoω could we keep in tοuch?

    Here iѕ my wеb sіtе; diamondlinks review

  21. It iis based on computer with electrographic
    sensor technology. It combines RPG elements and strategy for a
    very interesting game where you must stop the rows of pirates ship from making their way down the
    river. t love the unself-conscious little boy or girl, the undaunted miniature explorer who moves with unbridled enthusiasm to experience

    Feel free to visit my web site :: Homepage des Autors
    besuchen - -

  22. Try simple games and check how your internet connection is and then move on play more games.
    Age Level - A good factor to write about is the appropriate age level for the video game that you are reviewing.

    t love the unself-conscious little boy or girl, the undaunted miniature explorer who moves with
    unbridled enthusiasm to experience life.

    Visit my website - More hints